PharmD Info

A forum for Indian Pharmacy Professionals

Research Publication-Pharmacy, UGC Care List, Approved Scopus Indexed Journals, Free Publication Tools, Online Plagiarism Checkers,
  • User avatar
Learn how to find a Predatory journal using a "Journal Evaluation Tool" The journal evaluation tool includes two components, the rubric and the scoring sheet.

Follow the below steps to check the predatory status of a journal which you have selected.

Step 1: Follow the criteria listed on the rubric. The criteria prompt you to look to the journal and publisher websites to determine if there are markers of credibility or any red flags.

Step 2: Look at the Rationale column on the scoring sheet to gauge the importance of each criterion.

Step 3: Categorize each criterion on the rubric into one of three categories: good (receiving a score of 3), fair (a score of 2), or poor (a score of 1).

Step 4: Mark the score for each criterion on the scoring sheet. Step 5: Determine the final score after you have completed the rubric.

Step 6: Use the Guide to Interpretation at the bottom of the scoring sheet to determine if the total score suggests that the journal is likely a good, fair, or poor choice for publication.


Journal Evaluation Tool - Download
(217.27 KiB) Downloaded 26 times

Result Interpretation

48-38 Good: Within this range the journal meets many of the evaluation criteria defined for credibility. At the higher end of the range the journal would have the fewest credibility concerns.

37-27 Fair: Within this range the journal meets some evaluation criteria defined for credibility. The author would need to decide whether to publish in the journal.

26-16 Poor: Within this range the journal meets the fewest of the evaluation criteria defined for credibility.

The evaluation tool was developed and locally tested at LMU by Marie Kennedy ([email protected]), Shilpa Rele ([email protected]), and Nataly Blas ([email protected])
Similar Topics
Topics Statistics Last post
0 Replies 
by Admin
11 Feb 2020, 07:27
0 Replies 
by TeamPharmD
27 Jan 2018, 12:02
0 Replies 
by Smita_joshi_16
26 Nov 2019, 10:49
1 Replies 
by KauveryHospital
19 Dec 2020, 22:32
0 Replies 
by Admin
20 Feb 2017, 11:50

ICH GCP and Indian GCP differs on Investigator qua[…]


B Pharmacy PCI syllabus from First (I) to Eight (V[…]

There are different types of "recognitio[…]

PharmD Info - Highlights